A native of Washington D.C., McIntire earned his undergraduate degree in
Philosophy from Franklin & Marshall College in 2005. He took a minor in
Public Policy, with a concentration in International Relations and
Development in Latin America. In 2005 McIntire captained F&M's lacrosse team.
As an undergraduate McIntire studied for a term at the University of
Edinburgh, Scotland, and interned for a Washington D.C. policy research
organization with a focus on social and economic policy in Latin America.
His greatest accomplishment there was authoring a press memorandum delivered in Congress and published in the Congressional Record.
McIntire taught History, Writing and Philosophy at a private high school in
Ohio and coached lacrosse at Kenyon College. He later earned his M.A. from the University of Chicago, studying political philosophy and the philosophy of law, and writing his thesis on the philosophy of civil disobedience.